Showing posts with label Dismissal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dismissal. Show all posts

Monday, 28 January 2013

Go the full distance

We've all had players who could have their own highlights package made up of events during a game, whether it's the number of times they have made a telling pass, scored a hat trick or found themselves coming to the attention of the referee more than once.

I saw one such player a few weeks ago and in the main, the referee dealt with him well, but when it came to a crucial decision he went for the easy option. So let's have a look at the player first of all ...

He was a centre forward and a skillful one at that. He moved with pace and purpose but he also had that annoying trait that such players often have in that he had a streak of arrogance which led him to taunt his opponents. Now for those who have been involved in football for a while, we will all have encountered what the exponents refer to as "banter" or "bantz" as it's sometimes called on other websites.

This is the ability to make a stinging one line comment that undermines the efforts or achievements of an opponent (or even a referee), usually accompanied by a smile but often annoys the recipient so they retaliate, either physically or verbally and it is often the retaliation that gets more attention. Sometimes it's a fairly low level jibe, such as "Have a shot next time" to a player who has just missed the goal by more than 10 yards or "I'll get that" when a misplaced pass goes out for a throw-in or goal kick. Nevertheless, it rankles and gets under the skin of the person to whom it is directed.

This player came to the referee's attention early in the game when he used his long legs to kick the ball off an opponent's forehead, narrowly avoiding making contact with his eyes and nose. The referee correctly identified and penalised dangerous play. His next incident was a long crossfield ball of the type I used to marvel at when I first went to watch Billy Bremner and the Leeds United team of the 1970s.

His contributions began to come more frequently, holding, a trip, being fouled and then his first telling contribution to his team's win, a well taken goal from long range with a shot that fizzed past the hapless goalkeeper (why are goalkeepers always hapless? Most of them are very good at what they do!).

The game became a little ragged, as did his performance, as the heavy ground took its toll on his pace and that of his opponents. Challenges became less well timed and the free kick count mounted up. The player scored a second goal from a header but then he was on the end of a couple of rough challenges from the player trying to mark him and eventually the opponent was cautioned.

Now for some players a caution is taken as it is meant, it's a warning to change their behaviour or they might suffer the indignity of a dismissal and all that comes from that. So it was with this player, he began to jockey our star rather than commit the sliding tackles he had made previously and was more careful when making aerial challenges. Cue our star's mouth beginning to be used as to taunt the opponent. Now the referee identified this and spoke to the player, issuing him with a stern warning.

Having had the riot act read to him, you might think the player would have taken the hint, but he didn't. Even though the game was entering the last 10 minutes, he still was letting his mouth get the better of him. However, when he was dispossessed, close to where his opponents manger and subsitutes were standing on the touchline and they made some comments about him being a superstar, he launched into a challenge that many referees would recognise as being an "orange" card.

In hindsight, it looked like the challenge for which Vincent Kompany was dismissed a couple of weeks ago, but from the side rather than head on to the opponent. The referee reacted calmly and cautioned the player, which I felt was a little generous but I didn't have his angle on the challenge and was considerably further away than he was. The player's reaction was to begin a verbal spat with an opponent after he was fouled a minute or two later. The referee used the captain to help him explain to the player that he needed to change his behaviour.

So this player has committed an act of dangerous play, scored a couple of goals, had at least two verbal exchanges with opponents and /or their manager, been cautioned and had a couple of chats with the referee with his captain involved. In other words a really busy day and it would probably fill his week at work, as he retold the tale of the game. He wasn't finished there however and this is where the referee just didn't take the final step.

In added time, with his team coasting to an easy victory, in a game which had been virtually one way traffic for all of the first half and much of the second, the player did something stupid and childish. As the ball was in the air, he ran alongside an opponent and as the ball dropped towards their position, he made a noise like a fire engine siren, a sort of a "woo-woo-ooo-wooo" noise.

Now the referee quite correctly identified this as an attempt to distract an opponent and by the letter of the law, he should have stopped the game, cautioned the offender and restarted with an indirect free kick to the non-offending team. This would have seen the player receive a second caution in the same game, which would have meant his being dismissed.

Unfortunately this referee didn't do all of those things. He stopped the game and gave the free kick, but he omitted to issue the caution, choosing instead to issue a strong word of warning to the player. As I said to him afterwards, the ball was probably going to go out for a throw-in, so he could have waited until that happened and then issued his warning, but having stopped the game, he was obliged to caution.

He told me he knew what he should have done but just didn't do it. The good news was that he had done so many other positive things in the game, that they negated much of the impact on his mark and overall it was a good performance. It could however have been a great performance but hopefully if you/he encounter a superstar in the future and he does something similar, you/he will go the full distance and take the necessary action OR manage the situation by waiting to the next break in play to issue a strong admonishment.

Keep smiling (it unnerves the players!).

Saturday, 14 April 2012

But I got the ball...

This is another in my occasional series of blogs where I look at how incidents in open play can be broken down into elements as can be done with "set plays".
For every incident on the field, I run through a series of questions
  • Where is the ball?
  • Where are the players?
  • What infringements may occur or may have just occurred?
  • If an infringement has occurred, what action should I take ... if any?
This time around I'm going to look at how I consider challenges on the ground. I may have to stray into differentiating between careless, reckless and excessive force, but I'll try to avoid it (no chance!).

Where is the ball?
Hopefully if a player is challenging for the ball, he is in close proximity to the ball. This means being within the length of a leg away from the ball. I also consider whether he has unobstructed access to the ball - so has his opponent got his body (or any part of it) between the ball and challenger, for example is the ball being shielded by the player in possession?

Apart from the distance from the ball at the time of his challenge, the other factor I consider is the angle of approach of the challenge. The angle and distance give me a good idea of whether the challenge is going to be

a) legal
b) successful

A challenge from behind on a player running away from a challenger has less chance of being successful and more chance of being illegal than a face to face challenge. As the angle of approach moves from being face to face, there is a greater chance of the ball being partially shielded and therefore there is an increased risk of contact being made with the player in possession.

Where are the players?
I've often heard it said by commentators on the television "if that had been anywhere else on the field, the referee would have given that" when referring to a challenge made by a defender for the ball in his own penalty area. They are probably partially correct as the awarding of a free kick on the half way line will never present the same goal scoring opportunity that comes from a kick from the penalty mark.

So in the case of the free kick on the halfway line, it can be given when the offence is less obvious to those on the touchline/in the stands/50m away on the field. In the case of challenge that results in the awarding of a kick from the penalty mark, referees want to be certain that the offence is more obvious.

The other consideration is whether the players are attacking or defending. Attackers are, in general, less proficient at challenging for the ball than defenders. Therefore giving rise to the expression, "a forward's tackle".

What infringements may occur or may have just occurred?
This is the big one ...
  • shirt pull
  • body check
  • push in the back/front
  • kick on the ankle/shin/knee/thigh
  • trip from the front/side/back
All of which can happen
  • before the ball arrives
  • when the ball is present
  • when the ball departs (is passed)
How do I see whether an offence has occurred? I need to make sure I can see the point of contact by the challenger, also whether the contact is with the ball or his opponent. I need to see that from a credible distance of not much more than 15m (that's less than the distance across the centre circle). It may mean that I have to put in quick burst of speed (something that's getting more difficult as the years roll by) or that I may need to move around the players (which gets easier with the anticipation that experience brings). I need to ensure that my line of sight isn't blocked by players not involved in the challenge.

So I've considered the angle of approach and the distance travelled to make the challenge, i.e. from the point the challenge is initiated, I now need to consider the speed of the challenge and also the force used in the challenge

When I mention the force used (insert your own Star Wars joke here), I mean, is it proportionate to the required action needed to dispossess the player currently in control of the ball. It's an all too common occurrence that a challenger will want to take man and ball. The law was changed a couple of seasons ago to include reference to the fact that if a challenge is careless, reckless or using excessive force, then winning the ball is no defence.

The force of the challenge is dependent on the speed the challenger is moving at relative to the player in control of the ball and their relative directions. If two cars are moving at 20-30 miles per hour in the same direction and one slows slightly and the other one collides with it, the force exerted is less than if both cars hit head on or if one was stationary.

If an infringement has occurred, what action should I take ... if any?
I have a choice to make ... advantage or no advantage?

Even if an advantage exists, unless there is a goal scoring opportunity, if I am considering issuing a caution or dismissing a player, then I'm not going to play that advantage. I'm going to stop play, issue the sanction and have a controlled restart (on my whistle).

If the advantage exists, then I sweep up the arms, give the approved vocal command "Play on - Advantage" so everyone can see and hear it, then carry on with the game.

So how do I decide if I'm going to issue a caution or dismiss, well that's a story for another time (as they used to say on Hammy Hamster's Adventures on the Riverbank - look it up on Youtube!) but generally speaking, if a challenger is
  • coming in from any angle greater than 135 degrees relative to the direction the player in control of the ball is moving
  • has both feet off the ground as he initiates the challenge
  • uses both feet to challenge
  • is moving much faster than the player in control of the ball
  • is less likely to actually make contact with the ball, because the player in control of the ball is moving away from him
  • making contact with any part of the player in control of the ball, other than his foot
then if I have more than one of these boxes ticked, then I may have to consider doing more than just giving the free kick. I've had very few straight dismissals for challenges during my refereeing career (12 years and 2 days now) and most have been for 2nd cautions in the same game, but I am always aware of the possibility of needing to go straight to the back pocket.

So all that goes through my head every day when I'm in the run up to a game or a course. I also think about it when watching a game, so I can often tell whether a player is going to get a caution or a dismissal before the commentator makes reference to it.

Next time I'm going to look at playing advantage, when to do it and when not to.

Friday, 6 April 2012

Here comes the ball

Last Sunday I very rashly said I'd start a series of articles about the set plays which occur in open play, if that makes sense. I made the point that although we look after a series of set plays such as corner kicks, goal kicks and free kicks, the other situations which occur can also be treated as set plays. By treating them in this way, we can break down what we, as referees, can do to ensure we can apply law correctly and in the context of the game. I also said that I consider these situations during the week using the technique of mental rehearsal by visualisation.

I break each scenario down so I can answer 4 questions
  • Where is the ball?
  • Where are the players?
  • What infringements may occur or may have just occurred?
  • If an infringement has occurred, what action should I take ... if any?
So let's look at the first situation and depending on how I feel this one has gone, I'll do another next week. So here comes the ball ... the most frequent occurrence in a game ... the ball is passed by one player to another.

The Ball
It can be on the ground or in the air but does it matter? I ask this question because often, even when at a Supply League game, I see referees following the ball through the air. I'm not sure why as it will never ever make a challenge, push an opponent, kick an opponent or head butt an opponent ... all of which might happen while you're watching the ball fly through the air. So watch the ball leave the player passing it and watch it arrive at the player receiving it, but in between times, concentrate on the players.

The Players
Once the ball has been played I need to gauge where the players are and what they are doing. It's unlikely that I can see that from where I am, so I need to move. I need to move so I can see the ball brought under control. I need to move so I can see any challenge which might be made. I need to move to maximise the effectiveness of my proximity to play and retain credibility.

Infringements
The first infringement I have to think about it how the ball was played by the player making the pass. If he played it with his head or anywhere from the knee down, I'm happy. If he has played it with anything between his knee and his neck, then I had to be aware of the possibility of a claim for handball from his opponents. So that goes back to where the players are when the pass is made. Often a claim comes from someone who has a bad or long distance view of the contact, so if it's loud enough and I disagree I need to sell the denial. Sometimes a loud shout of "No!" is enough but other times, I need to "cut the grass" with an outward sweep of both arms and depending on how loud the appeal was, I might need to hold that position for a second or two (always being aware that it could take me off balance).

So I'm happy the ball has been played legally, but as it moves away I need to be aware of a late challenge by an opponent. This is the time when the ball is in the air or travelling along the grass. I keep my eye on the player who has passed the ball for a second or two before switching to the new situation ... the ball arriving.

The ball arriving is similar to the ball departing in that I need to see how the ball is controlled by the player receiving it. I check on the point of contact before deciding whether I need to sell a decision not to give a free kick for handball. Just as I did with the ball leaving I need to be aware of the possibility of a challenge by an opponent. That challenge might be aerial or on the grass, either way I need to have an angled view of the contact between the players which means moving around play to look through the challenge from the side towards the touchline, rather than towards the goal line.

Action required
I've already mentioned the "cutting the grass" to deny any appeals for handball, but that's when there has been no offence. So what do I do if there has been an offence. The first infringement would have been handball, so delay a second to see if the ball falls to an opponent and I can play advantage. If it does then out go the arms and a loud shout of "Play on - advantage". In one game about 4 years ago, I did that twice in a game after a handball claim and on both occasions, the team taking the advantage scored a goal!

If there is no advantage to be played, then a short blast on the whistle and once I'm happy the ball is in the right position, signal the restart. My signal will depend on the placing of the ball. If there's a possibility of a shot on goal or a cross into the penalty area, then I'll signal with the whistle, otherwise it might just be a shout or a beckoning arm signal.

If the offence is a late challenge, then again I look for the advantage but and it's a very big but, if I'm going to sanction the challenge with a caution or a dismissal, then I'm not playing advantage 99 times out of 100. The whistle to stop play will be blown harder and for longer and I'm also going to be moving towards the scene of the incident to discourage any retribution from team mates of the player offended against.

With the arriving ball, again if it's handball, then I'm on a quick, sharp blast or looking for advantage. The adjudging of the challenge comes in a number of forms, holding by either player, a kick/trip when trying to play the ball, pushing and I'll try to cover those in later blogs.

The thing is that once the player has taken control of the ball, we're the first step in this sequence. It's probably taken you a few minutes to read this far and yet as a referee, we have to run through the sequence of adjudging the pass and receipt of the ball hundreds of times a game. It's no wonder we are mentally as well as physically tired at the end of a game.

So now you see why it's important to go through the process of mental rehearsal, because by exercising the mind, it's similar to exercising the muscles, they need that work-out to be ready for game day and on the day, mentally warm up by thinking through a few scenarios.

Next time, I'm going to look at the challenge on the grass. All those two footed, off the ground, ball played. got the ball ref challenges we see every game.

Sunday, 22 January 2012

A game with everything

From time to time, life provides you with a reminder of things you know or knew but had allowed to slip from the forefront of your mind. Sometimes the realisation that you had forgotten them comes as an pleasant surprise, other times the memory stings a little as you realise you had been in denial about those forgotten facts.

Here are some things that I "re-learned" this morning as I made my return to active refereeing in the local Sunday League ...

- Credibility sometimes matters more than the correct decision
- The ability to sell a decision is inexorably linked to your proximity to play
- My eyes are faster than my brain which is in turn faster than my legs
- Sunday League players are fantastic people as are the people who run their clubs

Having covered these points, I will proceed with the match report from my return and I hope you're got the time to spare as it might be a little longer than my usual blog posts.

I arrived earlier than planned to find the club secretary and the players putting up the nets. As far as they were concerned, the field was fit and we were playing. On inspection I agreed with them. It was soft and very damp in some places but good enough for a game. I went to my changing room, got out of my tracksuit and headed out for my warm up. I didn't enjoy it as the wind was strong and the rain was drizzly. It didn't stop me spotting two piles of dog feces and I asked a club official to get them removed.

The team sheets arrived, everyone's name was written up in my notebook and I headed out to play but we had to wait a little while for the dog "deposit" to be removed. We got underway and I didn't have to give a free kick for almost 12 minutes, which was just as well as I was struggling to get my second wind. The field had a substantial slope and the central area was heavy, so I tried to run around rather than through it, meaning I had to run a lot further than I really wanted.

The first big call came on half an hour, just after the home team's opening goal and involved a player I've refereed many times. He made a reckless challenge and became the first player I have cautioned in nearly two years. I was about 5 yards from the incident, he acknowledged I was right and we got underway without much fuss. His team scored their second goal soon afterwards with a lovely piece of play.

The ball was played up the right wing and was flicked nonchalantly overhead by the right back, then again by the right midfielder (wing back?) and the attacker ran towards goal as I shouted to the defender challenging him for the ball not to pull him back. The forward broke free before rounding the goalkeeper and passing the ball into the goal.

The away team struck back almost immediately with a counter attack and then 2 decisions in quick succession changed the complexion of the game as we entered added time at the end of the first half. From my angle I could tell the home player had committed an act of dangerous play with his foot up at shoulder height, but I couldn't see if he made contact with his opponent, so I awarded an indirect free kick. The offending player challenged the decision and I responded by making sure he moved back the required distance before moving into position to observe the drop zone.

As the ball flashed into the penalty area, a home central defender inexplicably stuck out his left arm as the ball was heading towards the goal line for a goal kick and instinctively I awarded a kick from the penalty mark. A goal was scored, we kicked off and I immediately ended the half.

The second half started off quietly but the first of my points above comes into play. The away team pushed up the hill, the attacker tried to go around the goalkeeper who dived to gather the ball and the attacker fell down. The manner in his fall suggested there was no contact and I stopped play before cautioning him for simulation. It was the right decision at the time and playing the incident back in my head, it still feels and looks like the right decision. The problem was that I made it from the halfway line, some 45 yards from the players and that made it the wrong decision and more difficult to sell.

The player took umbrage and upped his effort levels, scoring a good goal just a minute later. He then threw himself (fairly) into a challenge and got injured. According to a team mate after the game, he spent yesterday afternoon in the casualty department of the local hospital with an injury to the same knee, but this looked serious and he had to be carried off the field of play.

This only happened after I had been harangued by his girlfriend when I asked her to move off the field of play. She had wandered 10 yards infield as I adopted a position to allow me to observe his assessment and the remainder of the players. The team manager looked a little embarrassed as he had to usher her off the field. His team scored another goal 4 minutes later to double their lead and the game seemed to be settling into a pattern of long ball football as both teams tried to avoid the centre of the field which was now resembling a quagmire.

On the back of the lack of credibility of my decision to caution for simulation I worked harder at closing down my proximity to play. In the 72nd minute I spotted a reckless challenge near the corner flag when I was only 10 yards away. I also ran towards the players so that as the offender looked for me, I was standing almost on top of him and the player he had illegally challenged. The player was cautioned and then a few minutes later he committed another reckless challenge and was dismissed. His response was to use OFFINABUS language towards me before leaving the field. His team conceded another goal 10 minutes later and we were soon all done.

I did my warm down and felt my cramped muscles easing so much that I was able to run upstairs to my changing room to check I had all my kit. I noticed that the door to the changing room had sustained three holes, low down, as if it had been kicked, since I went out for kick off. I didn't see it happen so can only have my suspicions.

A quick drink in the bar after the game (blackcurrant and soda water) allowed me the time to have a chat with some of the players and club officials. One of the players suggested he was thinking of being a referee and I told him I thought he'd do a good job (no bs as he reads the game well and is very fair). We had a few laughs about playing FIFA12 before I headed home to write up my reports and have a warm bath.

Game done, reports sent and recovery jog planned for tomorrow night.

Saturday, 19 November 2011

Two sides

An interesting game today as the home team from last week were the away team.

Pleasantries were exchanged before the game and off the field but after 2 cautions and a dismissal for the away team, the referee was accused of playing up to the assessor (me). Nothing could be farther from the truth. While in last week's game, they had been on the receiving end of a fairly physical appoach by their opponents, this week, they snapped and harried at most early challenges.

The home side reacted in kind and the result was a game littered with poor challenges and appropriate disciplinary action. In the end the team in black won, with 6 cautions and 1 dismissal and for the first time this season it took me until 7:30 to get the heat back into my toes.

Movember Day 19 by the way. If you want to give, go to http://mobro.co/BrianHamilton

Monday, 28 December 2009

BBC Sport - Football - Referee Adrian McCourt scared after sending off five

mccortleavesBBC Sport - Football - Referee Adrian McCourt scared after sending off five

Irish League referee Adrian McCourt said he was worried about his safety after sending off four Crusaders players and their manager at Seaview (click above link for more info).

Sunday, 30 August 2009

Not so friendly after all

Despite my legs of lead, I'd promised a friend that I'd do a game for him this morning.

It started easily enough and I worked overtime explaining to players that I was unhappy with a few things, but avoided reaching for my pocket. Everything went well until it reached half time or more accurately about 35 seconds before it. A nothing tackle turned into an argument, some headbutts and two dismissals. The only people who disagreed with the dismissals were the two players involved.

The game restarted for the second half and I did some more running. The home team lost 5-1, my friend was happy, despite the heavy defeat and explained that he'd told his team they would learn more about referees in 90 minutes with me than he could teach them in a season (he's a retired level 5 with 5 years experience).

I took the compliment, calories 1302 (lazy but reflects the pattern and standard of play), max hr 86%, average 71%

Thursday, 27 August 2009

Game 5

This was the last of my scheduled midweek fixtures and featured a local team recently relegated from their Supply League. The visitors were another team local to where I live and I've refereed them regularly over the last few years, most noticeably just before Christmas 2007.

The away team were delayed by traffic problems on the M62 but we got away pretty much on time. The game was relatively easy to manage and the recent heavy rain meant the ball was flashing across the greasy surface with a lot of speed. Well it would it either team had played the ball along the ground. They only seemed interested in kicking it up in the air and either heading it or running after it. The skill factor seemed to be non-existent.

A long ball played to the left wing saw a home player chasing it but not before he was wiped out by the opposition centre half. The away team had taken a comfortable 2-0 lead at this stage and the game seemed to be grinding towards a conclusion. Half time saw the home team come back out with more purpose and despite conceding a 3rd goal, they fought back and scored a goal of their own.

Then we had the incident that changed the mood of the game. A challenge by the player already cautioned, saw him commit another cautionable offence and he became the second player to be dismissed in 5 days in one of my games. Shortly afterwards I awarded a penalty to the home team and the goalkeeper protested too much and collected a caution for dissent. The penalty was scored to make it 2-3 but the away team scored almost immediately to restore their 2 goal advantage.

Another late goal for the home team saw a frantic last few minutes but the away team ran out worthy winners in the end. Calories 1538, max hr 91%, average 76%